By - DANNY YADRON
Category - Six Flags Magic Mountain
Posted By - Hampton Inn Santa Clarita
 |
| Six Flags Magic Mountain |
Wireless companies have long sold cellphones at discounted prices in
exchange for long-term service agreements. The catch: Consumers can't
easily take what would otherwise be an expensive smartphone to a rival
carrier who offers a better price while the phone is under contract.
Tech-savvy users have used computer programs as a workaround to
unlock their phones. But last fall, the Library of Congress, which has
oversight of certain copyright matters, banned the practice if a carrier
doesn't give permission, saying cellphones should no longer be exempted
from a section of copyright law. The move went into effect in January,
prompting a backlash from activists who flooded a petition on the White
House's website.
By the time the White House responded Monday, the "Make Unlocking
Cell Phones Legal" petition at the White House's website had garnered
more than 114,300 digital signatures.
"Consumers should be able to unlock their cellphones without risking
criminal or other penalties," R. David Edelman, an Obama administration
adviser on Internet and privacy issues, said in the official response to
the petition. He called the position "common sense" and "crucial for
protecting consumer choice."
The White House said consumers should still be required to honor service agreements.
Both AT&T Inc.
and Sprint Nextel Corp.
already allow customers to unlock their phones after they have
fulfilled their contracts, but activists call the procedure cumbersome
and say users should be able to do it on their own. The latest phones
from Verizon Wireless, a joint venture of Verizon Communications Inc.
and Vodafone Group
PLC, come unlocked, a spokeswoman said.
The wireless industry defended their current practices.
"Customers have numerous options when purchasing mobile devices,"
Michael Altschul, general counsel for the wireless industry group CTIA,
said in a statement Monday. "They may choose to purchase devices at full
price with no lock, or at a substantially discounted price—typically
hundreds of dollars less than the full price—by signing a contract with a
carrier."
The Library of Congress's rules
establish federal copyright penalties for unlocking a cellphone.
Wireless carriers can collect statutory civil damages of between $200
and $2,500 per violation and criminal penalties can rise to $500,000,
five years in prison or both for the first offense.
The response by the White House marks the latest effort by Washington
to cater to Web activists, who have used a mix of online organizing,
email blasts and occasional in-person protests to shape how Washington
regulates new technology.
Internet message-board regulars and corporate titans such as Facebook Inc.
Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg
effectively killed antipiracy bills in Congress last year that had
seemed likely to become law. Many lawmakers said the heated and
organized response caught them off guard.
"People are just waking
up to the impact they can really have," said Derek Khanna, a former
technology staffer on Capitol Hill, who helped marshal support for the
cellphone petition. "It's not just stopping bad legislation. They can
really put new ideas on the table."
A former staffer for the Republican Study Committee, a leading group
of House conservatives, Mr. Khanna wrote a memo last year that called
for the liberalization of copyright law. The RSC retracted the report
and said it didn't support it.
The RSC couldn't be reached for comment Monday.
Mr. Khanna said he received a phone call Monday from the White
House's Mr. Edelman informing him of the administration's response
shortly before the statement was posted online.
The White House confirmed the phone call but wouldn't comment on the discussion.
Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski
recently said he intends to look into the issue of unlocked cellphones, a
move the White House said it would support. It is unclear what
regulatory authority the commission has in this case.
